Picture this: a buzzing insect approaches your picnic or outdoor gathering. Someone quickly suggests hanging a brown paper bag, claiming it will scare them away. It’s a classic backyard hack, but the big question is, does a brown paper bag keep bees away effectively? Let’s dive into this popular theory and uncover the truth.
Contents
The Buzz Behind the Bag: Wasp Nest Mimicry
The idea behind hanging a brown paper bag is quite clever in theory, but it’s primarily aimed at one specific insect: wasps. Wasps are known to be highly territorial creatures. If they spot what looks like an existing nest in an area, they’re generally less likely to build their own nest nearby. The crinkled, brownish shape of a crumpled paper bag is thought to mimic the appearance of a dormant or abandoned wasp nest, thereby signaling to any passing wasps that the territory is already claimed.
So, the hope is that by tricking wasps into believing there’s already a nest, they’ll simply fly on by and choose another location to set up their home or forage for food. It’s a passive deterrent strategy that relies entirely on a visual illusion.
Bees vs. Wasps: A Crucial Distinction
Before we go any further, it’s really important to understand the difference between bees and wasps, because their behavior and what deters them can be very different:
- Bees: These amazing insects are often fuzzy, rounder, and have broad, flattened legs adapted for carrying pollen. They are primarily vegetarians, feeding on nectar and pollen, and are vital pollinators for our ecosystem. Bees are generally non-aggressive and will only sting if they feel their hive or their lives are directly threatened.
- Wasps: In contrast, wasps tend to be sleeker, smoother, and have a more defined “waist.” They are predatory, hunting other insects, but also enjoy sugary foods and drinks. Wasps are often more aggressive than bees, especially when their nest is disturbed or they feel cornered.
The brown paper bag trick is specifically designed to deter wasps due to their territorial nature regarding nests. Bees, on the other hand, don’t operate the same way. They aren’t looking for a new place to build an individual nest if they see another, and they aren’t territorial in the same sense around solitary foraging. They are more interested in food sources and flowers, making the paper bag less relevant to their behavior.
Does It Actually Work? The Verdict for Bees
While some anecdotal evidence suggests the paper bag might occasionally deter a wasp (or sometimes, just seem to work because the wasp was going to leave anyway), scientific backing for this method is largely absent. For bees, it’s even less effective. Bees are not fooled by a paper bag “nest” because their social structure and nesting habits are quite different from those of wasps.
Most experts and pest control professionals agree that relying on a brown paper bag to keep bees or even wasps away is unreliable at best and often completely ineffective. It’s more of a myth or a folk remedy than a proven deterrent. If you’re dealing with a persistent bee or wasp problem, you’ll need more robust strategies.
More Effective & Bee-Friendly Ways to Deter Pests
Instead of relying on a dubious paper bag, here are several proven and bee-friendly methods to keep unwanted buzzing visitors at bay, focusing on humane deterrence, especially for our precious pollinators:
1. Essential Oils
Many essential oils are natural insect repellents. Bees and wasps generally dislike strong scents like:
- Peppermint
- Citronella
- Clove
- Geranium
- Eucalyptus
- Lemongrass
Mix a few drops of your chosen oil with water in a spray bottle and mist around outdoor dining areas, window sills, or entry points. You can also soak cotton balls and place them in strategic locations.
2. Natural Repellents
- Cucumber Slices: The bitter compounds in cucumber skins are believed to deter wasps. Place slices around your patio or near food.
- Garlic: Crushed garlic can create an odor that many insects, including wasps, find unpleasant.
- Mint Plants: Planting mint in your garden or placing potted mint plants on your patio can help keep a variety of insects away.
3. Smoke
Smoke disorients and calms bees and wasps, making them less likely to sting. This is why beekeepers use smokers. For outdoor gatherings, burning citronella candles, incense, or even a small campfire can help deter them.
4. Remove Attractants
This is one of the most effective strategies. Bees and wasps are drawn to food and water. Eliminate what attracts them:
- Cover Food & Drinks: Keep all food, especially sweet items, covered when outdoors.
- Clean Spills Immediately: Sugar spills are irresistible.
- Secure Trash Cans: Use cans with tight-fitting lids.
- Pet Food: Don’t leave pet food and water bowls outdoors for extended periods.
- Standing Water: Repair leaky faucets, empty bird baths regularly, and remove any containers that collect water.
5. Seal Entry Points
If insects are finding their way indoors, check your home for gaps. Seal cracks in foundations, walls, and around windows and doors. Ensure screens on windows and doors are in good repair.
6. Traps (for Wasps, with Caution)
While not ideal for bees, you can use traps for persistent wasp problems. DIY traps often involve a bottle with a sugary bait (like soda or fruit juice). Commercial wasp traps are also available. Remember, traps should be a last resort and placed away from areas where people gather to avoid attracting more wasps to your immediate vicinity.
7. Call a Professional
If you have a large nest near your home, particularly if it’s a wasp or aggressive bee species, or if anyone in your household has severe allergies, it’s always best to call a professional pest control service. They can safely remove the nest without harming you or, in the case of bees, often relocate them humanely.
Conclusion
While the brown paper bag trick is a widely shared piece of folk wisdom, it’s largely ineffective, especially when trying to figure out does a brown paper bag keep bees away. Bees are vital pollinators, and our goal should always be to coexist peacefully with them while deterring them from areas where they might cause a nuisance. By understanding what attracts these insects and employing more reliable, humane strategies, you can enjoy your outdoor spaces with less buzzing worry.